Butterflies Are Free (1972)
(On Cable TV, March 2022) Mentioning the “theatrical origins” of a film is often either a way for me to talk about the hermetic, low-stake nature of its plot, or a lead-in to the better-than-average dialogue that the adaptation carries over. It’s rarer, but not impossible, for such a theatrical adaptation to lead to a good film that keeps the strengths of its play while working just as well cinematically… like Butterflies are Free. Anchored by strong performance by Goldie Hawn and Edward Albert (even though it’s Eileen Heckart who won an Academy Award for her supporting performance), the film takes a look at a free-spirited young woman as she discovers her new apartment neighbour—and realizes that he’s blind. He has his own issues to work through—most notably a domineering mother who has given him a month to prove that he can live on his own. The repartee between those two young people is quickly complicated by the mother barging in and disapproving of the budding relationship. It doesn’t quite go where you expect it, though. Even today, much of Butterflies are Free’s last third still has a freshness of approach—whether it’s the growing rapport between the two women, or some last-minute swerves on the way to a happy ending. Butterflies are Free is not, to be clear, that good of a play nor a film—but it’s surprisingly accessible and even engaging once it gets going. It’s a fun watch, and it manages to keep the qualities of its original even as it delivers a decent adaptation.