False Positive (2021)
(On Cable TV, January 2022) There’s something incredibly primal about making horror movies about pregnancy, and while that can provide a strong narrative hook, exploitation always looms. False Positive definitely has a few strong moments, but it ultimately falters on its blend of delusion and reality, an underwhelming conclusion and a sense that it’s not doing the extra work to go beyond obviousness. Writer-star Ilana Glazer makes the jump from comedy to serious drama in an effective fashion—she’s rarely less than likable at first, and then a heroine that we’re willing to follow to the end of the film even as her fantasies become more unhinged. (Pierce Brosnan is also quite fun as the out-and-out villain of the piece.) The slow but growing sense of unease is built effectively, and False Positive rarely holds anything back as it seeks to disturb viewers—first with unpalatable choices then with outright gore. But two or three things harm the film in its ending stretch. I’m not going to be overly critical of the film’s “all men are garbage” stance, because that’s fairly standard material for the current crop of women-focused horror films (even more so with pregnancy-focused films) and we can postpone having a discussion about that unexamined assumption for a while longer. I’m more concerned by the story settling on a trite resolution that essentially apes daytime-TV specials with more gore and horror. (Yes, I know that fertility doctors impregnating their patients is a real and terrible thing—but that plot has been done many times already as Lifetime movies of the week, and False Positive only differs in tone, not story.) The other problem is that False Positive flirts with something better but does not commit to it: in showing the protagonist’s descent into pregnancy delusions, it sets up a shaky sense of what’s-real-and-what’s-not that is scarcely capitalized upon in the end. A much punchier ending is held back by writer-director John Lee’s refusal to go further in literalizing the protagonist’s craziness. Let’s commit to her being the surrogate mother for her garbage husband and her evil doctor. Let’s go to the end of her imagining a magical holistic doctor. Let’s uncover a eugenics conspiracy by evil white men and committing infanticide as a result. But no—Maybe it’s real, maybe it’s not, maybe I just don’t care after being jerked around. Messing around with primal matters carries with it a responsibility to do justice to the material, and this is where False Positive falls flat.