Barfly (1987)
(On TV, November 2022) I can’t say that I’m much of a Charles Bukowski fan, but I’ve read one or two of his books, and it’s hard to avoid his boozy street-poet influence on American literature. Accordingly, I was disappointed by semi-biographical drama Barfly. The film tries to present a Bukowski stand-in (played, appropriately enough, by classic-era Mickey Rourke) through a few days of dead-end existence in the dregs of downtown Los Angeles—fighting, stealing and drinking being the main events. Much of the story revolves around his courtship and relationship with a kindred woman (Faye Dunaway), and the temptation of escaping his situation. It’s all consciously seedy and considering that Bukowski himself wrote the script, you really can’t accuse the film of being unfaithful to his writing. And yet, there’s more to a film than a screenplay—Bukowski sent mixed messages about the film in the years following its release, going from admiration to reservation, although he did get a book (called Hollywood) out of his experiences during the film’s production. In the end, though, it feels like a restrained version of the Bukowski legend—and it’s useful to acknowledge that Bukowski’s persona is often far more interesting and cinematic than his lived-in reality as he wrote it for the screen. This is one project where an exaggerated version of the character could be more interesting than the character itself. Something to reflect upon when we keep dinging Hollywood for “printing the legend” when it invented that technique to make its audience happy.