(In French, On TV, March 2020) Considering the star-power on display in Tequila Sunrise, I was expecting quite a bit more than an overly convoluted love triangle between law, crime and a pretty woman. Writer-director Robert Towne has a history of complex plotting, of course, but penning Chinatown isn’t quite the same as the overcooked, overlong disappointment that we have here. Paradoxically, the film would have been better (or at least closer to expectations) had it not featured Mel Gibson, Kurt Russell and Michelle Pfeiffer in the main roles—their natural charisma is such that we expect a lot more from this trio than the somewhat humdrum drama that follows. (It’s technically a thriller, but there’s clearly more of an emphasis here on romantic drama rather than suspense or action.) Still, anyone will have to admit that the film occasionally has a few strong moments, and fully leans into a wonderful 1980s California noir kind of aesthetics. The plotting is complex enough to be engaging, and the re-use of noir archetypes is fun if you’re familiar with the tropes. Tequila Sunrise remains a disappointment, but at least it’s a good-looking one.
(On Cable TV, August 2021) If I had more time and intelligence, I would probably try to poke at the notion of performative cinema – if that’s the right word for it: Movies that don’t relate to the real world as much as they take bits and pieces from other movies and then try to perform those bits as maximally as possible. Melodrama of cinema, perhaps? Suffice to say that calling Tequila Sunrise as neo-noir is putting things mildly: it lifts and tweaks and reuses entire swathes of film noir, relying on big-name actors and glossy cinematography to paper over some glaring plot issues. Prime-era Mel Gibson and Kurt Russel play old school friends who are now on opposite sides of the law, with the cop being more devious than the criminal trying to go straight. In-between them is Michelle Pfeiffer as nightclub, er, restaurant owner playing both men’s romantic affections. And then there’s a greater-scope villain hovering over everything in a way to make the cop justified and the ex-criminal more likable. Set against golden-hued (i.e.: smoggy) Los Angeles, it’s often beautiful to look at but close to nonsensical once you start taking a look at the details. Fortunately, the film makes up in charisma what it lacks in plausibility: by the time a terrific Raul Julia steps into the movie, his garrulous performance more than excuses the plotting problems that come with him. Tequila Sunrise may not make much sense, but it’s very entertaining and a truly fascinating piece of second-order cinema taking its cues from other movies. It makes perfect sense in a neo-noir retrospective – with the caveat that it may lead to an appreciation of the film largely tinged with irony and references to older cinema.