The Turkey Bowl (2019)
(On Cable TV, September 2020) There’s a straightforward earnestness to The Turkey Bowl that compensates for a multitude of sins, perhaps the biggest one being that the script seems made of three familiar formulas thrown in a blender. You’ve got the young urban professional of humble origins getting a few second thoughts as his marriage to an upper-class fiancée approaches. You’ve got the return to a Midwestern town complete with the old flames, old friends, old rivals and old home with old bedroom intact. Finally, you’ve got the football game subplot, a fifteen-year-later attempt to recapture glory whose outcome is never once in doubt. Shot and set in Oklahoma, The Turkey Bowl often gives the impression of having been conceived there as well: There’s a notable lower-budget lack of polish to the result, whether it’s the dull cinematography, merely adequate actors, or slack editing. It’s not a bad film, but it’s a wholly average one, with very little to strike out as being distinctive one way or another. The formulaic nature of the plot means a few things: it allows casual watchers to drop in and out of the film to go make themselves a sandwich without fear of losing much of the plot, and, more importantly, it offers a lot of comfort to viewers. In that way, it’s not too dissimilar to a Hallmark channel romance: we know how it’s going to end, we know how it’s going to get there and there’s little active participation involved. There is certainly a public for this kind of thing, and every those who would turn their noses up to such populist filmmaking have to admit that it works even if it doesn’t exceed any expectations. Writer-director Greg Coolidge does just fine with what he has in hand, and there’s plenty of merit in turning in a good-enough movie. The Turkey Bowl may play best in a situation reminiscent of its title: A thanksgiving afternoon filler, with the family resting from a heavy turkey lunch and not wanting anything too challenging to interrupt the digestion.