Deathtrap (1982)
(On Cable TV, January 2021) Murder mystery and theatrical metafiction meet in Deathtrap, an enjoyable and unpredictable dark comedy starring Michael Caine and Christopher Reeves. It opens on Caine as a playwright experiencing a fourth failure in a row and retreating to his rural mansion, where he explains to his wife that he just read the most brilliant play by a complete novice, and the best plot he can think about is to murder the young writer and steal the play. Shortly thereafter, he invites the apprentice playwright home… but saying more would be a disservice, so quickly does the film go through different narrative configurations. Christopher Reeves plays the younger writer with an edge rarely seen in other films from him—not only does Deathtrap feature an explicit homosexual kiss (albeit as a mark of villainy—the early 1980s weren’t that progressive), but there’s a shot that makes him look like a maniacal Bruce Campbell at some point. The somewhat forgotten Dyan Cannon (whose career peaked between 1969 and 1982) has a decent role here, but the stars are clearly Caine and Reeves, especially as their antagonism becomes more explicit. Given the film’s origin in a long-running, widely acclaimed play by Ira Levin, there are plenty of metatheatrical references to be found (“It’s a two-act play with five characters,” says one of the five characters of a two-act play…), which adds both to its comedy and wittiness. The limited number of characters, dark comedy, secluded location and featured role for Caine immediately draw parallels with 1972’s Sleuth, but while both movies belong to the same subgenre, they’re sufficiently different as to make a great double feature rather than repeat themselves. (You could also make a double feature with 2019’s Knives Out, considering the wall-of-weapons and mystery-writers-getting-into-the-business motifs.) The metafiction carries through to the climactic ending, which seems cheap at first glance but appreciates with time. Even with its quirks, Deathtrap remains a very enjoyable comic thriller, not always audience-friendly at times but certainly surprising and memorable.