Greenland (2020)
(Amazon Streaming, May 2021) When the dust will settle, the memories of our COVID/lockdown years will definitely affect the way we make and approach entertainment. Already, I’m fundamentally less amused by zombie movies, and even catastrophe films are feeling less fun now that we have a new baseline against which to measure world-changing events. In taking a look at Greenland, for instance, I’m more inclined to question some of the base assumptions of the film than playing along with it. Part of it is the recent re-demonstration that a strong society works better than rugged individuals at facing down a great peril. In this light, having a film about a man judging that he and his family deserve to be saved rather than everyone else strikes me as distasteful, not matter how cleverly the film tries to weigh down its moral scale. (Meteor strike; pre-approved list of people to save; everyman trying to save his family; etc.) What makes the protagonist better than anyone is not satisfactorily demonstrated here, especially as he often relies on the unsaved to save himself. Yes, yes, I know — the film is meant to be an episodic series of mini-adventures on the way to shelter, and that’s it. But Greenland doesn’t help itself by featuring some fundamentally irritating plot cheats and complications, often presenting a caricatural portrait of other people that the protagonist has to overcome. For Gerard Butler, this is another solid role in a middling thriller: as usual, he’s better than the film he picks, but at the same time feels like an interchangeable part of a generic ensemble — I liked Morena Baccarin a lot more as his wife, but then again, I would in just about any film regardless of her part. There’s a bit of contrived lifeboat ethical dilemma here, and those often end up being ludicrously didactic lessons in semantic bullying, and I don’t think that Greenland, even under the guise of a lightweight apocalyptic adventure, is too far away from that. Director Ric Roman Waugh does have a sure hand on his handling of a large-scale spectacle, at least, which softens the blow slightly. I’ll at least grant that when it comes to disaster films, Greenland doesn’t pull back on spectacle while still presenting a relatively plausible depiction of how it may happen. I probably would have enjoyed the film a lot more a few years ago; I probably will like it more in a few years. Right now, however, it feels slightly distasteful and egotistical.