(On Cable TV, June 2020) There’s really one reason to watch Jailhouse Rock, and it’s not the plot, in which a hoodlum goes straight after discovering the power of music. Who plays the lead role, though? Elvis Presley, and he’s the reason why the film is still worth a look. While fans will debate whether this is Elvis’ finest film, most will agree that the title number is The King’s finest moment on-screen: shot like a music video with an expressionistic set, it shows Presley at his absolute prime. The plot, in which a young man goes from convict to musical sensation to Hollywood star, is not bad but it’s not original. As a showcase for the young Presley, however, Jailhouse Rock is nothing short of fantastic and does give justice to The King in his early glory. What exceeds expectation is Presley’s willingness to play an unlikable character—one who starts the film by killing someone with his own bare hands, then spends the rest of the film ready to smash guitars and faces at the slightest opportunity. Making a bid for a bad-boy image, Elvis doesn’t quite know he’s a star yet—but the camera suspects something is up. It’s a disappointment that the film is shot in black-and-white, but then again it wasn’t working with a particularly high budget to begin with. Still, Jailhouse Rock does have another distinction: helping to birth a new kind of musical, away from Broadway inspirations and more closely aligned with then-burgeoning pop music.
(Second Viewing, On Cable TV, June 2021) Clearly meant to be an Elvis Presley vehicle –his second top billing after Loving You, but the first built from the ground up for him–, Jailhouse Rock is interesting to modern viewers as one of the inflection points in between the classic Hollywood musical and the modern rock video. It’s obviously one of the first films to embrace the rock-and-roll offshoot of rhythm and blues, as it’s about a young convict learning guitar in prison, then going on to stardom as his songs go from relatively sedate numbers such as “Don’t Leave me Now” to catchier “Treat Me Nice” to the faster-paced “Jailhouse Rock” (still acknowledged as Presley’s most memorable screen number) before coming down romantically in time for the finale. Regrettably shot in black-and-white, it was meant as a fast and cheap production rather than an MGM flagship and the seams show – aside from the title number, almost self-contained in its choreography and visual presentation, the film is a by-the-numbers take on the sudden-stardom ur-story, with a dash of romance, business drama and personal growth thrown in. For Elvis, his characterization as a short-tempered, physically violent ex-con (wow, that scene where he walks in an office and starts slapping a records executive!) must have bolstered his bad-boy image – it’s not exactly a heroic role, but it works in context. It’s easy to watch Jailhouse Rock today and see its place as a transition between a certain idea of what a musical film should be, and what it would evolve into later on – with the exact recording of a pop hit taking over the interpretations that, until then, had dominated the genre. It’s alternately naïve (due to sticking to a familiar narrative template) and a bit off-putting due to the lead’s constant violence. But Jailhouse Rock remains well-worth seeing for the title number alone, and for the rest if you’re even a casual Elvis fan.