George Washington Slept Here (1942)
(On Cable TV, February 2022) It’s tempting to compare George Washington Slept Here with Mr. Blandings Builds His Dream House. Both films, after all, are Classic Hollywood comedies about an urbanite (played by an actor with significant comic credentials) who moves to the country and experiences numerous difficulties trying to achieve his rural dream. But the differences are obvious early on: Jack Benny is no Cary Grant, and his first scene, in which he verbally harangues his black servant, is not an endearing one at all. Spending much of the film being annoyed at the protagonist (who spends his time complaining about everything, and barely seems to like his wife) is no way to enjoy a film, and it takes just about everything—most notably a spirited turn by Charles Coburn as a secretly-destitute uncle—not to shut down the whole thing. Now, I strongly suspect that I don’t know enough about Benny’s persona to be sympathetic to it: seen cold, he just seems like a miserable, bigoted, hateful miser and that’s a very poor foundation for any comedy. George Washington Slept Here does have a few chuckles (plus a lovely Ann Sheridan), but it never quite escapes the bad first impression left by its star, nor the far better memories of the admittedly flawed Mr. Blandings Builds His Dream House.