The Moguls aka The Amateurs (2005)
(On TV, March 2022) While The Amateurs didn’t make much of a splash upon release, you can go back to it today to have a look at an eclectic cast out for an amiable comic romp. The fact that it’s about small-town people getting together to make an amateur pornographic movie isn’t much of an obstacle for prudish audiences—while this is technically an R-rated film, it features nothing worse than some mild language (albeit fewer swearwords than you’d expect), lingerie and a bit of rear nudity. The treatment of the topic often feels like older people tittering at a risqué subject more than anything else, but that’s the kind of film it wants to be—an American The Full Monty, Kinky Boots or Calendar Girls. That’s perhaps not such a surprise considering the respectable cast it managed to get together: Headlined by Jeff Bridges, it also features notables such as William Fichner, Tim Blake Nelson, Joe Pantoliano, Ted Danson, Lauren Graham and Jeanne Tripplehorn in supporting roles. Sharp-eyed viewers will even spot Judy Greer in a regrettably short role. The big joke of the film is that none of the main characters are attractive enough to disrobe, and there’s slim pickings in casting an erotic film in a small town. Much of the humour comes from the clash between plans and reality, with Bridges’ character narrating but not adding that much to it. The Amateurs has to navigate a tightrope act between being suggestive but not vulgar, as well as finding a way to give something to its characters despite setbacks along the way. It generally manages to make it to the finishing line, although the ensemble nature of the film makes it difficult to focus all that long on each of the dozen subplots all going on at once. No one will reasonably claim that this is a forgotten gem, but it plays reasonably well if you’re in the right frame of mind and don’t expect too much from the result. The cast and small-town atmosphere can be interesting even if more dirty-minded viewers will be left unsatisfied.